Black Swan

I went to go and see Black Swan a couple of weeks ago, and the time it’s taken to get this written up is partially due to the fact I’ve been so busy, and partially due to the general feelings (or lack of feelings) that I have towards the film.    Detailing the preparation a ballerina goes through in preparing for a production of Swan Lake the film also deals with the main characters fragile mental state beginning with what appears to be mild paranoia and with this building up further and further to the rather strange finale.  On one level it could be looked at the main characters ambition to fulfil the part reaching so deeply that she becomes the role she is trying to portray.

The biggest problem for me with this film was that I couldn’t get a handle in with any of the characters.  Natalie Portman gave what I’m sure if a fantastic performance but it left me feeling cold and uncaring towards her.  Barbara Hersheys performance as the mother trying to live her dreams through her daughter was suitably disturbing, but the other characters seemed more like caricatures of people not quite fully rounded – the supporting character who came closest to this was Winona Ryder s character Beth – but she was given such little screentime that you only really got hints of what was going on.

Stylistically the film was very good – the camera swops right in during the ballet sequences taking you straight into the action, pulling you in so you can see the faces of the dancers.  As the main characters mental state becomes more and more fragile you get some more bizarre scenes involving – what is in her eyes – a transformation from human to a swan.  This is something that the film does very well, blurring the lines between reality and the imagination constantly leaving you wondering whether what  you have seen was real or not real – the only problem with this is that towards the end of the film this blurring is a lot less effective and it becomes no surprise when a supposedly dead character pokes their head round the door.

Overall as a film it didn’t really grab me in the way I needed to be grabbed – as previously stated I couldn’t find a connection with the characters so I couldn’t care for them whilst this was going on.  It was an interesting look into how obsession with your work can affect you, but I left the cinema without feeling the need to see the film again.  It’s a certainly a strange one this one possibly the best way to describe it would be the unintended pun I made leaving the cinema.

“That film was ducked up.”


3 thoughts on “Black Swan

  1. I’m surprised you didn’t enjoy this one! I found it an incredibly powerful piece of drama and thought Natalie Portman’ performance was absolutely convincing. The story stuck with me for days as I pondered over the costs of immersing oneself so completely in an experience that it becomes you. I thought the ending was spot-on; it couldn’t have gone any other way, but at the same time it is suitably vague as to what, precisely, did happen. Adobe believe the ending of the film as we initially see it, or is it just another level of the character’s delusional mind?

    I would agree, though, that some of the characterisation was weak. Thomas’ character was particularly poor, and I would have liked to have seen more of Beth.

    Oh, and if you should ever see the film again (I’m guessing you won’t!), watch the scene with the “supposedly dead character” poking her head around the door; I think you may have missed something!

    • More than willing to give it another go – but think I’ll wait for the DVD… I don’t know if it’s because I expected something else from the film that I didn’t enjoy it quite so much… It was very effective with generating a creepy feeling and it may just be that that I didn’t like…

  2. I’ve heard mixed reviews about this film. I’m sure it’s powerful but to be honest, everything I’ve heard about it doesn’t exactly make me want to go out and see it. It doesn’t exactly sound like an easy watching kind of movie!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s